There is a dilemma at the heart of the NHS – but politicians don’t want to talk about it

Nigel Lawson, one term chancellor of Margaret Thatcher, famously stated that the NHS is “the closest thing the British people have had a religion”.

Definitely, according to UK census records Declining adherence to Christianitycelebrating and crying about “us” NHS” brings together citizens of all faiths and political views.

Everyone is afraid of pain and disease. The longing of those who founded the NHS this was to separate real concerns from concerns about being able to pay for money and care.

The NHS would pay through taxation and make all treatment “free at the point of delivery”.

For many people, the idea that healthcare should not be paid for by the individual has become an article of faith.

This week, his deduction that he opposed this rule provided an effective line of attack against the prime minister, who is also a multimillionaire.

After days of struggle by the media and political opponents, Rishi Sunak finally confessed at PMQs “I am registered with an NHS GP,” he protested, saying he had “used independent healthcare in the past”.

If you are an NHS worker and would like to share your experiences with us anonymously, please email

What does ‘free’ really mean?

In reality, nowhere is the distinction between “free”, taxpayer-funded health care and good, private medicine as clear-cut. Mr. Altar‘s can suggest awkward moments.

Most NHS users make some form of personal “co-pay” for services each time they receive a prescription.

According to the Office for National Statistics, at least 13% of adults paid for private medical care in the last year.

And just to keep up with current inadequate levels of treatment, the NHS itself relies heavily on contract workers and services from the private sector.

Read more:
“Climbing on people… there’s blood on the floor”
Nurse miscarried after five hours of A&E wait

When the NHS was founded in 1948, the official brochure sent to all households explained its basic principles.

Everyone, rich or poor, man, woman, child, can use it or any part of it.

“There are no fees except for a few items. There is no insurance requirement. But it’s not ‘no’. You all pay taxes, money relieves you of your sickness.”

From the start, the sidebar phrase “except for a few items” betrayed that not everything would be completely free.

Some services may require some payments from some patients.

Nye Bevan, the minister who founded the NHS, resigned from the Labor government when accusations were brought for “teeth and glasses”—dental treatment, dentures, eyeglasses and surgical instruments.

A few years later, a Conservative government introduced prescription fees. All of this is still relevant today, even as the cost of healthcare for the nation has increased 10 times.

The NHS budget in 1948 was £437m – the equivalent of about £16bn in today’s money.

The NHS budget for 2023-24 is set at £160.4 billion, subject to strikes and subsequent emergency funds to deal with the “health care crisis”.

Read more:
A&E expects to reach new high
Worst region in England in terms of handover times

From GPs to social care, the NHS order is full of anomalies

There are other anomalies in the way the NHS is set up: family doctors are supposed to be the gateway to treatment in the NHS, but GPs have been left out of the system. While their applications are small businesses on their own account, in hospitals; doctors, nurses and technicians are employed by the NHS.

Technically, taxpayers do not pay directly to the NHS, but contribute to the budget for “health and social care services”.

But social care – caring for people in need at home or in nursing homes – was left out of the “free” principle and was underfunded as a result.

The absence of properly funded care, coupled with a growing proportion of older people in the population, has led to so-called “beds clogging” in hospitals and underpaid care workers compared to those doing a similar job in healthcare.

Attempts by various governments to find ways for families to contribute more to the cost of care have backfired. in 2017 Theresa May’s care offers were soon dubbed the “dementia tax.”. An earlier Labor plan was branded a “death tax” by Tory finance spokesman George Osborne.

Read more:
Are NHS failures responsible for extra deaths?
What happens to the body while waiting for the ambulance?

Meanwhile, more than seven million people are on the waiting list for NHS treatment.

Waiting times are increasing in A&E departments and ambulances that transport patients to hospitals. Britain’s “over-deaths” are significantly above average.

Once again, the relationship between the NHS and private healthcare is seen by some as a solution and by others as a problem.

Some NHS hospital trusts buy surgeries in private hospitals – even French hospitals – for their patients.

Government plans to “buy” beds in nursing homes to get people out of hospitals.

On the other hand, some trusts tell those on the waiting list that if they go private they can get their surgery quickly – often using facilities in the same hospital and with the same NHS staff doing additional work.

Statistics show that overall delivery of NHS services was at its best in the first years of this century, after Tony Blair and Gordon Brown raised funds for the NHS to the European average for per capita health expenditure.

Since then, England has again lagged behind.

Using OECD data, the King’s Fund reported that when compared to most of the rest of the Western world, the UK has one of the lowest numbers of doctors, nurses and hospital beds per population.

Read more:
NHS ‘clearly not working’
Pharmacy manager warns of famine

Will people pay more?

Debate continues as to whether a lack of funds or inefficient bureaucratic organization is responsible for the NHS crisis.

The public’s belief that healthcare should be “free” does not make the solution any easier. Opinion polls show public sympathy for wage demands and higher pay for the NHS for nurses, doctors and paramedics.

However, this generous spirit does not go very far in practice.

In a detailed survey by Redford and Wilton Strategies, asking “how much more tax the British people would be willing to pay to raise more funds for the NHS”, 43% said they would not pay more, and 24% set the maximum extra £100. Only 11% said they would pay over £500.

Read more:
‘I’ve never seen anything like it’
NHS workers describe daily ‘fire fight’

Does labor have a serious solution?

The Labor Party says its sweeping “NHS Plan”, outlined by Sir Keir Starmer and Wes Streeting, will pay off with the end of overseas status and without bothering most UK taxpayers.

This is quite ambitious, as Labor proposes to end staff shortages by doubling the number of medical school places and district nurses; 10,000 extra nurses and midwives and 5,000 more health visitors each year.

It’s also unclear how these long-term supply-side measures will “end the Tory crisis,” as Sir Keir argues.

In its 75-year history, the NHS has been run by both Labor and Conservative governments, and they have faced the same challenges.

True, in most years since the 2008 banking crisis, the NHS has been financed below the average annual increase of 4% it had expected since the 1950s.

But at that time, funding levels were never a significant point of difference between the parties.

Read more:
How many empty beds does your local hospital have?
New COVID variant is fastest growing strain in UK

Behind the rhetoric, recent attempts to unravel the NHS are cross-party.

The government has appointed Patricia Hewitt, a former Labor health secretary, to lead the review of the new integrated health boards. Both sides are developing long-term training programs to end staff shortages.

But the “free” NHS is so popular that even though healthcare needs and available treatments are so different from those in 1948, politicians are afraid to question its underlying principles and order.

Voters want more without having to pay more. Rather than confronting patients or healthcare professionals with this dilemma, it’s easier to polish up old grievances and yell about what happened, including Mr.

Leave a Comment